California Bar Journal
OFFICIAL PUBLICATION OF THE STATE BAR OF CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 2000
spacer.gif (810 bytes)

TRIALS DIGEST

spacer.gif (810 bytes)

Assault at high school
Award: $910,000

A sales clerk sued for negligent supervision after an assault during an athletic event at Venice High School caused brain damage (Brown v. Los Angeles Unified School District, Los Angeles County Superior Court).

Insurer lies about coverage
Award: $31,166,298

An insured claimed bad faith by an insurer in lying about policy coverage and ignoring the duty to defend (Earnest v. Truck Insur-ance Exchange, Orange County Superior Court).

Treadmill found defective
Award: $660,000

A woman was thrown off a malfunctioning treadmill purchased from Sears (Choulkes v. Icon Health Fitness, Los Angeles County Superior Court).

‘Sick building’ alleged
Award: Defense

Tenants in a commercial building claimed that water leaks caused toxic mold and fungus contamination (Tarp v. E&W Associates III, Fresno County Superior Court).

Muslim discrimination claim
Award: $1,000,000

An engineer claimed national origin/religious discrimination after he was replaced on a project and denied a promotion (Rez v. City of Los Angeles, Los Angeles County Superior Court).

Negligence after childbirth
Award: $530,415

A couple claimed negligence in the treatment of a perineum tear and reconstructive surgery after the birth of their child (Casadei v. Norris, Los Angeles County Superior Court).

Failure to accommodate
Award: $500,000

A post-polio syndrome sufferer claimed his employer failed to provide reasonable accommodation on the job (Chan v. County of Los Angeles, Los Angeles County Superior Court).

Fall from loading dock
Award: $711,660

A construction manlift operator aggravated a lumbar disk when he fell from a loading dock (Bonilla v. Hensel-Phelps Construc-tion, Sacramento County Superior Court).

Unfair business practice
Award: $911,000

A lender’s notice of default for a violation previously ignored was found to constitute an unfair business practice (Rigel Corp. v. Citicorp North America Inc., Orange County Superior Court).

Leased copier malfunctions
Award: $3,870,000

A customer claimed breach of contract and fraud regarding the lease of a high-speed copier (Doe v. Roe Corp., San Mateo County Superior Court).

EDITOR’S NOTE: California Bar Journal publishes this abbreviated summary of important trials in California provided by Trials Digest Publishing Inc. For a free complete trial report on any case listed, call 510/420-1800.