California Bar Journal
OFFICIAL PUBLICATION OF THE STATE BAR OF CALIFORNIA - NOVEMBER 2000
spacer.gif (810 bytes)

OPINION

spacer.gif (810 bytes)
The buck starts here
spacer.gif (810 bytes)
By DOROTHY TUCKER
spacer.gif (810 bytes)

Dorothy TuckerGuess what? Attorneys are a lot more noble than most people think. Not because they claim it, but because of some powerful data that has emerged in a recent survey. But just like so many other changes that have occurred in modern society, it may well be that financial contributions have replaced the concept of pro bono or free labor.

Attorneys, it turns out, are extraordinarily philanthropic people. The “news” was one of the high points in a survey distributed to the 15,700 members of the Foundation of the State Bar of California in July.

The backdrop for this discovery lay in the incredible growth of annual member contributions to the foundation over its nine-year history — a span during which members have given $3.75 million. Between 1991 and 1999, foundation revenues soared from $154,196 to $681,679, an increase of 342 percent.

During the same period, salaries of first-year associates increased by 237 percent, according to a national study. Granted, there are imperfections in comparing California foundation contributions with national salaries. Yet one conclusion is inescapable: During the past decade, attorneys in California have contributed their share — and then some.

What is motivating attorneys to be so generous?

That’s what the foundation recently asked as one question in a survey of its members. The results are rather amazing.

Forty-six percent said they give to the foundation because “it’s the right thing to do,” followed by another 32 percent who support the foundation’s scholarship and law-related education program.

In other words, more than three-quarters of the respondents say they give because they believe in the foundation’s mission.

Support for next year looks equally promising. Some 78 percent said they would give again because of the foundation’s program and objectives. Less than 3 percent said they would not give again. It’s hard to imagine many other voluntary organizations with such high retention rates. Further, such member satisfaction creates the opportunity for the foundation to “spread the word” in hopes of expanding the donor base.

Why such high levels of member satisfaction? Part of the answer stems from general agreement with the foundation’s two primary giving categories: scholarships and law-related education programs. When asked for their input on future giving patterns, 45 percent replied that it should remain as is; 16 percent asked for more money for scholarships; and 19 percent called for more funds for law-related programs. Conclusion: The foundation’s distribution pattern seems to be right on the money.

Far from being myopic in their giving patterns, foundation donors are generous in a number of other areas as well. Some 68 percent give to their undergraduate college or law school; 61 percent donated to religious organizations; 44 percent gave to youth or senior organizations; 37 percent donated to a child’s or grandchild’s school; 38 percent contributed to local bar associations; and 33 percent gave to the annual United Way campaign.

Clearly, the giving record of attorneys is one to be proud of. Using the past decade as a guide, California attorneys are giving at rates faster than the rate of income growth. And if the past decade is any indication, growing numbers of attorneys will be giving a lot more to their foundation and communities in the years to come.

Dr. Dorothy Tucker is president of the Foundation of the State Bar of California.